TY - JOUR PY - 2012// TI - Behaving badly or goodly: Is it because I feel guilty, shameful, or sympathetic? Or is it a matter of what I think? JO - New directions for youth development A1 - Carlo, Gustavo A1 - McGinley, Meredith A1 - Davis, Alexandra A1 - Streit, Cara SP - 75 EP - 93 VL - 2012 IS - 136 N2 - The article provides a brief review of theory and research on the roles of guilt, shame, and sympathy in predicting moral behaviors. Two models are presented and contrasted. The guilt-based model proposes that guilt and shame jointly predict prosocial and aggressive behaviors. In contrast, the sympathy-based model suggests that perspective taking and sympathy are linked to such behaviors. In both models, prosocial moral reasoning is proposed as a possible mediator in these relations. Results from a study of college students suggest support for both models. Moreover, there is evidence that prosocial moral reasoning mediates the relations between these moral emotions and moral behaviors. The implications for the need to incorporate moral emotions and cognitions into existing models of morality are discussed and emphasized.
Language: en
LA - en SN - 1533-8916 UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/yd.20040 ID - ref1 ER -