TY - JOUR PY - 2019// TI - Re-evaluating competence to stand trial JO - Law and contemporary problems A1 - Collins, David SP - 157 EP - 189 VL - 82 IS - 2 N2 - The American federal law governing a defendant's competence to stand trial is substantially contained in 18 U.S.C. ยง 4241, which can be traced to a 1949 statute, and in Dusky v. United States, a three-paragraph opinion the Supreme Court delivered in 1960. The term "competence to stand trial" refers to a defendant's ability to "participate" in her trial. It includes those who plead guilty and those who are to be sentenced. This article critically examines the current federal law governing a defendant's competence to stand trial in the federal criminal jurisdiction and explains why it is antiquated and no longer fit for purpose. It proposes a new test whereby competence would be determined by reference to the defendant's capacity to participate effectively in his trial.

Language: en

LA - en SN - 0023-9186 UR - http://dx.doi.org/ ID - ref1 ER -